0.2% (94) negative reviews to sales
Average on Squaremouth is 0.2%
5 stars
356
4 stars
101
3 stars
71
2 stars
31
1 star
63
Detailed Ratings
Customer Service Before Trip
Customer Service During Trip
Customer Service During Claim
Please enter the date your trip begins. This should be the day you leave your home.
Please enter the last day of your trip. This should be the day you return home.
Please enter your destination country. If you are traveling to multiple destinations, please just enter one. The policies on our site provide coverage across multiple countries.
TOTAL SALES
42,109
Since 2018
MONTHLY SALES
325
Average Monthly Sales Since 2018
REVIEWS
622
Since 2018
Overall Rating
4.02 out of 5
Overall Rating 4.02 out of 5
622 Reviews Since 2018
Customer Reviews for Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company
Sort by Most Helpful, Most Recent, Star Ratings, or select “Filed Claim” to only show reviews from customers who filed a claim.
Filed claim on their website on 12/09/23. Did not receive a confirmation email. On 12/14/23, I emailed claim information to the company. On 12/20/23, I phoned and spoke with Angelo and he supposedly assigned a claim number. He stated it could take 3-4 weeks. I have not heard or received anything from the company. A bit disconcerting.
Review Updated: 01/23/2024
In late December (after waiting several weeks) I received an email requesting additional information needed in order to complete the claim. I promptly sent the information and have heard nothing back! I have filled out the login information three times and it does not work. I have no idea what the status is. I can't login to find out because it doesn't work. The coordinating company hasn't worked well for me since the claim started back in mid-December. The money involved is becoming a hardship. I have purchased travel insurance through SquareMouth numerous times and have been satisfied. Unfortunately, I may need to reconsider next time.
Was this review helpful to you?
17 out of 17 people found this review helpful
Rating 1 out of 5
Policy:
Essential
Review Received:
December 26, 2023
ACB from NJ
Verified Squaremouth Customer
We are trying to get the cancellation fee for our Holy Land tour (Israel, Jordan, Egypt) from Nationwide. Trip was cancelled due to the act of terrorism and the on going war in that region. Nationwide is citing all sorts of irrational policies on what they deem a terrorist incident. Per this disreputable insurance company: The act must be deemed an act of terrorism by U.S. Department of State or the law enforcement organization in charge at the location of the Terrorist Incident.” The US government has deemed 100723 a Terrorist Incident but no other incident was deemed a terrorist incident by the Us government. War was declared after this incident and the policy has and exclusion which applies “4. war, invasion, acts of foreign enemies, hostilities between nations (whether declared or not), civil war. This is an on-going act of terrorism, and this insurance company is doing everything they can to get out of their customer obligations. Disreputable! The travel agency refunded the whole amount of the tour with the exception of a non-refundable fee of $400, which we are claiming from Nationwide. Even this amount they refuse to reimburse us, but we are rebutting their decision and will continue to fight this claim. This is not just for the money but for the principle involved! I would stay away from this company since they are disreputable. They severely fail to perform as an insurance company and function primarily as the recipient of insurance fees while projecting the illusion
that your travel fees are covered!
Was this review helpful to you?
27 out of 27 people found this review helpful
Rating 4 out of 5
Policy:
Essential
Review Received:
December 18, 2023
WHAdministrstor from CA
Verified Squaremouth Customer
Upon arrival at CUN airport we were informed of “serious delays” and after some stress called Nationwide International Help desk. They were polite and attempted to inform but overall we felt we were on our own. Booked an alternate flight home at great expense and now awaiting process of our claim submitted on 12/12/23. Not a word beyond an auto reply email acknowledgement so far.
Was this review helpful to you?
16 out of 16 people found this review helpful
Rating 3 out of 5
Policy:
Essential
Review Received:
December 18, 2023
Joseph from NY
Verified Squaremouth Customer
Happy that claim for $1500 was fully paid within 2 weeks of filing, with no negotiation.
The claim submission process could have been smoother and that led to some confusion.
The claims website allowed for electronic submission of materials, but only accepted one document for each "type" of information. For example it was necessary to put all the medical documents in one file in order to upload them. After filing we learned there is a general email address for further document submission.
We received a few confirmation emails. But it was never clear if a response to that email would be read or used. I sent some documents to that email by mistake. They need to clearly state "don't submit documents here" if the email is purely a notice.
I got a very ambiguous answer to the email question "have you received all the required documents". The response was a letter listing all the filing requirements and a section bolded related to the the explanation of benefits of another insurer. I guessed the response meant "you still need to submit the EOB" but they should have just come out and said "We have these five things, you don't need to send your credit card statements, and we are still waiting for the EOB".
It sounds like growing pains as this TPA migrates to an electronic platform. It would have been very stressful to do all this by mail.
Was this review helpful to you?
11 out of 11 people found this review helpful
Rating 1 out of 5
Policy:
Essential
Review Received:
December 17, 2023
John from VA
Verified Squaremouth Customer
My trip to Israel on November 28, 2023 was cancelled due to terrorist activity in cities on our itinerary from October 7 - November 28, 2023. Nationwide Mutual Insurance denied my claim and appeal stating they only cover terrorist acts within 30 days on the trip departure date and October 7 was more than 30 days from the trip departure date of November 28. I appealed the decision as there were other terrorist acts in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv (both cities on my itinerary) in the month of November. There was no further explanation from Nationwide for their denial of my appeal. We will be further appealing this most recent claim denial. If Nationwide had approved our initial claim and made the process smooth, we would have been loyal customers for life as we regularly travel overseas. However, now we will never purchase travel insurance from Nationwide and we will tell everyone our experience and recommend they do NOT use Nationwide for travel insurance.
Was this review helpful to you?
15 out of 15 people found this review helpful
Rating 1 out of 5
Policy:
Essential
Review Received:
December 8, 2023
Gayle from TX
Verified Squaremouth Customer
My trip was to Israel, and we purchased insurance to cover our trip. Ill never bother to purchase insurance again. War broke out in Israel, and we were too anxious to pit ourselves in danger of being kidnapped or killed. Insurance would not cover the cost of our trip, so we are out the approximately 4K each we paid. The rep at Nationwide told me that we had no choice but to go or lose the money.
Was this review helpful to you?
16 out of 16 people found this review helpful
Rating 4 out of 5
Policy:
Essential
Review Received:
November 30, 2023
darron from NJ
Verified Squaremouth Customer
Lost my JR rail pass, which was a travel document, by which they said they do not cover. Disappointing
Was this review helpful to you?
6 out of 6 people found this review helpful
Rating 5 out of 5
Policy:
Cruise Choice
Review Received:
November 24, 2023
Gary from OH
Verified Squaremouth Customer
Nationwide handled our trip interruption extremely well. The service provided by One Call international was thorough and we were treated well. Our claim after being flown home was handled professionally and to our satisfaction.
Was this review helpful to you?
9 out of 10 people found this review helpful
Rating 4 out of 5
Policy:
Cruise Luxury
Review Received:
November 23, 2023
Linda from NY
Verified Squaremouth Customer
Trip was cancelled due to war in the Middle East
Was this review helpful to you?
3 out of 3 people found this review helpful
Rating 5 out of 5
Policy:
Essential
Review Received:
November 20, 2023
Luis from LA
Verified Squaremouth Customer
I got the coverage I wanted at a reasonable price.
Was this review helpful to you?
2 out of 3 people found this review helpful